A Report on the Automattic Ecosystem By the Naturalist
To observe the current instability within Automattic and the wider WordPress ecosystem is to observe a superorganism in the throes of a "queenless" transition. The departure of Matt Mullenweg—the Benevolent Dictator for Life (BDFL)—on a leave of absence is not merely a corporate vacancy; it is the sudden evaporation of a systemic pheromone.
In the study of Eusociality (the highest level of social organization), we find that the stability of a colony—be it of Apis mellifera (honey bees) or Solenopsis invicta (fire ants)—depends upon the production of primer pheromones by the queen. These chemicals do not "command" the workers in the human sense; rather, they inhibit the ovarian development of the subordinates. The pheromone is a signal of presence that suppresses the drive for independent reproduction.
The BDFL serves as this chemical anchor for the open-source project. By holding the trademarks and the final word on the "canonical" direction of the software, the BDFL inhibits the "ovarian development" of the ecosystem—the tendency of various factions to fork the code or seize the brand for their own reproductive success. The "benevolence" of the dictator is the stability of the signal.
However, we must also attend to the Keystone Species (as defined by Robert T. Paine). A keystone species, such as the sea star Pisaster ochraceus, maintains the structure of its community by preventing a single species from becoming dominant. The BDFL is the keystone of the WordPress arch. The "open-source" nature of the platform is the habitat—a vast, nutrient-rich pond created by the BDFL's engineering, much like the wetlands fashioned by the beaver (Castor canadensis).
The current dispute with WP Engine is the evidence of a "trophic cascade." When the BDFL's signal becomes erratic or aggressive—or vanishes entirely—the inhibition fails. The "workers" (the developers, the hosting companies, the plugin authors) no longer feel the suppressing presence of the anchor. They begin to develop their own "ovaries"; they seek to define the trademark and the direction of the project themselves.
The paradox of the BDFL is that the very decentralization they foster is only possible because of their central authority. The "open" ecosystem is a luxury provided by the dictator's willingness to be the single point of failure. When the keystone is removed, the arch does not merely shift; it collapses into a state of competitive frenzy.
We are witnessing the "point of no return" in a digital colony. If the pheromone is not restored, or if a new, accepted queen does not emerge from the brood, the superorganism will fragment into a series of smaller, solitary, and perhaps more honest, but less massive, entities.
References:
/n/wiki/Eusociality/n/wiki/Keystone species/n/wiki/Automattic/n/wiki/WordPress